- Oversight & Council Questions System
- Case videos
- Pingtung's budget looks great, so where's the money? The Sichongxi hot spring public bath at 5.33% execution
EP35 · Number check
Pingtung's budget looks great, so where's the money? The Sichongxi hot spring public bath at 5.33% execution
We lined up the National Audit Office reports, the magistrate's election bulletin, procurement notices and a Control Yuan report: the Sichongxi public bath spent NT$3,731,000 of NT$70 million, the cold-chain line will not be handed over until 2027, and the tourism projects were flagged by both the Control Yuan and the auditors.
- Capability
- Number check
- Published
- Length
- 2:59
- Format
- Long-form (16:9)
Original YouTube title: 屏東縣府預算寫得很好看，那錢呢？四重溪溫泉公共浴室執行率5.33%
The method behind this video
- Open the National Audit Office report on Pingtung's 2024 final accounts, table "construction projects with annual execution below 80%": the Sichongxi public bath rebuild has a total budget of NT$115 million, NT$70 million available that year, NT$3,731,000 spent, a 5.33% execution rate, and a schedule ending November 2026.
- Check the same table in the 2025 report: the total is revised to NT$121,216,000, all of it available, with NT$16,097,000 spent, 13.28%. Two years of spending add up to NT$19,828,000, under a fifth of the total, with opening promised for this November.
- Compare item two of the magistrate's 2022 election bulletin, "export steam-heat cold-chain packaging plant and processing facility", with procurement notices: the phase-three line, budgeted at NT$500,258,768, failed its first tender and was only awarded on 2026/1/13, with performance estimated to January 2027; CNA reports handover in February 2027, while the magistrate's term ends this December.
- Match each tourism promise with its progress: the Gaoshu Ecological Wilderness Park design and supervision contract was only awarded in November 2024; the Jialeshui international mountain-and-sea park costs over NT$660 million and runs 2026 to 2029; the Control Yuan's Hengchun Peninsula report flags tourism statistics, cross-agency governance and operations; the auditors' 2025 report says the indigenous village tour reports were incomplete, approved items were not carried out, under half of the shuttle drivers held professional licenses, and tours lacked emergency medical equipment.
- For the Hengchun tourist railway, read the Railway Bureau's project page: the feasibility study went to the transport ministry on 2025/10/31, review comments came back on 12/31, a revision was resubmitted on 2026/3/31, and on 5/26 the ministry asked for another revision and resubmission.
Related videos
Sources
- National Audit Office, audit report on Pingtung County's 2024 final accounts (Sichongxi public bath project, annual budget execution rate 5.33%) ↗auditreport.audit.gov.tw
- National Audit Office, audit report on Pingtung County's 2025 final accounts (Sichongxi execution rate 13.28%; findings on indigenous village tours) ↗auditreport.audit.gov.tw
- National Audit Office, 2025 Pingtung County audit findings, item 10: tours and visitor safety in the indigenous nature and culture landscape area ↗auditreport.audit.gov.tw
- Chou Chun-mi's platform in the 2022 Pingtung County magistrate election bulletin (Central Election Commission) ↗eebulletin.cec.gov.tw
- Cold-chain packaging line A024-1141121-1: notice of failure to award, 2025/12/29 ↗web.pcc.gov.tw
- Cold-chain packaging line A024-1141121-1: award notice, 2026/1/14 ↗web.pcc.gov.tw
- CNA, 2026/8/2: Pingtung's international packaging and cold-chain plant to be handed over in February 2027 ↗www.cna.com.tw
- Gaoshu Ecological Wilderness Park: award notice for planning, design and supervision services, 2024/11/28 ↗web.pcc.gov.tw
- Control Yuan investigation report on tourism in the Hengchun Peninsula and Kenting (including the Jialeshui project) ↗cybsbox.cy.gov.tw
- Railway Bureau, MOTC: planning status of the Hengchun (Pingnan) tourist railway (MOTC review and resubmission record) ↗www.rb.gov.tw
Video description
Show video description
The Sichongxi hot spring public bath has a total budget of NT$115 million. In 2024 the project had NT$70 million to spend. When the National Audit Office counted at year end, NT$3,731,000 had actually been spent, an execution rate of 5.33%. The auditors put it in the final accounts report. Opening is expected this November.
In the magistrate's own 2022 election bulletin, item two is an export steam-heat cold-chain packaging plant and processing facility. Phase one passed acceptance in January 2025, the phase-three production line was only contracted this January, and handover is set for February 2027. The magistrate's term ends this December.
The bulletin promised tourism diversity and more visitors. The Gaoshu Ecological Wilderness Park, NT$260 million, was still in basic design last May; Jialeshui, NT$660 million, is scheduled through 2029. The Control Yuan investigated tourism on the Hengchun Peninsula and wrote that statistics, governance and operations all need improvement; on indigenous village tours, the auditors wrote that reporting of results, implementation and visitor safety were all inadequate.
The Hengchun tourist railway was revised and sent to the transport ministry in March, and in May it was told to revise and resubmit again. The budget looks great, so where's the money?
Adapted from the published video description. Watch the original for the full content.
Your district can produce questions like these.
Start with a 30-minute call about the issues you want to follow and your office's daily workload.
More case videos
-
EP17 · Long-form
Number check
Pingtung's Department of Labor and Youth Development: the youth budget nearly quadrupled while the labor budget fell by more than 20%. Labor comes first in its name
The department's budget for 2023 and for this year, the Ministry of Labor's inspection figures, and the selection record of a NT$430 million building project, set side by side.
Watch and see the method → -
EP06B · Shorts
Number check
2,018 community group grants from Pingtung County, and a report that is NT$22,760,000 off
2,872 grant line items added up row by row, then checked against the report's summary-page total and the previous version of the notice.
Watch and see the method → -
EP09 · Shorts
Number check
Nearly 60% of Pingtung County tenders drew a single bidder. Do you have to dream it up before you can bid?
958 award notices read one by one for the number of bidders, to work out how many tenders drew only one.
Watch and see the method → -
EP21 · Shorts
Issue discovery
A single bidder: does it always mean something is wrong? Three explanations, three kinds of traces
For single-bidder tenders, list three possible explanations and the traces each one leaves, then check cases one by one to decide which to investigate first.
Watch and see the method → -
EP08 · Shorts
Petition routing
NT$13,190,000 to repair a leased building, with only a year and a half left before it goes back? Pingtung's Artisan Town
The grant's stated purpose did not match how the building is used, so the issue went to the National Audit Office, which has the authority to act; it has replied that it will open a special investigation.
Watch and see the method → -
EP14 · Shorts
Issue discovery
The county's youth channel: 26 of its latest 30 videos have under 100 views
Public view counts set against the project funding in the award notice, to find a question worth asking.
Watch and see the method → -
EP18 · Shorts
Issue discovery
What if a county voucher scheme used the "three-shop system"? Could an event like this go ahead? (Part 2)
The structure of the three-shop system applied to a voucher event, producing a hypothetical question the responsible agency can be asked to answer.
Watch and see the method → -
EP18 · Shorts
Issue discovery
Why is Japanese pachinko legal? The three-shop system, one legal step at a time (Part 1)
Explain the three-shop system first, then carry the same structure into Part 2’s hypothetical county voucher scheme.
Watch and see the method → -
EP20 · Shorts
Number check
Seven panelists: how many votes do insiders need? A purely hypothetical calculation
A hypothetical seven-member committee shows how its roster, attendance and votes can change the selection structure.
Watch and see the method → -
EP15 · Shorts
Issue discovery
Applicants miss out on the entrepreneurship course while an instructor keeps winning contracts
Line up government training, park tenancy and tender records to question a park shop’s role in managing Artisan Town.
Watch and see the method → -
EP12 · Shorts
Issue discovery
Young people do not stay. Has the county followed up?
Use audit findings to examine demand, funding and departure reasons in a youth employment grant, turning retention into an answerable question.
Watch and see the method → -
EP11 · Shorts
Petition routing
Blacklisted by the county? A lawful records request meets the same barrier
Compare the legal basis of a records request with the agency’s reply, then ask why an information request was treated as a repeat petition.
Watch and see the method → -
EP10 · Shorts
Number check
Communications selection panels: nearly 60% insiders, only 3.4% academics
Compare selection panels from 55 communications-department contracts with the median across 18 county agencies.
Watch and see the method → -
EP19 · Shorts
Petition routing
Artisan Town’s seismic assessment: the county replies “Article 173, no action”
Follow the assessment, opening and later safety listing to pursue a seismic report that cost NT$900,000.
Watch and see the method → -
EP25 · Long-form
Issue discovery
One company cleaned Pingtung County Hall for eleven years, with one bidder for four years: why I held this story
Track eleven years of cleaning procurement and include competition conditions and frontline cleaners’ wage protections in the questions.
Watch and see the method → -
EP24 · Long-form
Number check
Pingtung contracts over NT$100 million: awards within 1% of budget? Checking three figures one by one
Recalculate budget, award price and bidder count, then use the same method to compare counties and cities.
Watch and see the method → -
EP23 · Long-form
Petition routing
What does a local government look like when no one above it is watching? No Control Yuan members, no agency taking up prosecutors’ findings, county replies citing Article 173
Trace sixteen petitions and agency replies to locate where oversight stopped, then turn to public accounts and procurement checks.
Watch and see the method → -
EP42 · Long-form
Number check
A NT$500 million production line, NT$768 under budget | No bidders the first time, one the second
Four best-value tenders above NT$100 million: we read every tender, failed-tender and award notice, measured how close each award came to budget, then checked the panel lists.
Watch and see the method → -
EP01 · Shorts
Petition routing
The shop picked by the county's expert panel moved out in six months | Pingtung Artisan Town Black Box EP.1
Two letters to the magistrate's mailbox and the county's replies, set against the winning shop closing within six months, to ask what the department's “higher score” claim rests on.
Watch and see the method → -
EP02 · Shorts
Petition routing
Where are the expert ghost panelists? | Pingtung Artisan Town Black Box EP.2
The selection-day recording, the scoring weights and two written county statements side by side, to ask who the “expert external panelists” named in official letters and sent to the Control Yuan actually are.
Watch and see the method → -
EP03 · Shorts
Petition routing
The county's own event, and the county says it has nothing to do with it? | Pingtung Artisan Town Black Box EP.3
The county press release, the ethics department's phone answer and the department's written reply, compared: an event the county hosted, at a county venue, run by the county's contractor, and the county calls the incident a private matter it cannot step into.
Watch and see the method → -
EP04 · Shorts
Petition routing
Halloween at Artisan Town. If something goes wrong, who answers? | Pingtung Artisan Town Black Box EP.4
The ethics department's claim that the county owes no security duty at an off-site event, set against the county's press release and reports of the director announcing the reopening and leading the Halloween parade, to ask who residents turn to if something goes wrong.
Watch and see the method → -
EP31 · Shorts
Number check
Pingtung's Hakka central library budget grows to NT$375 million, and the central government adds nothing
We set the same line of the county's original budget and first supplementary budget side by side: the Hakka central library went from NT$300 million to NT$375 million, the NT$270 million central subsidy did not move, and the extra NT$75 million is all county money; the construction tender again drew a single bidder.
Watch and see the method → -
EP29 · Long-form
Issue discovery
The children wait while you deliberate: 745 early-intervention cases in Pingtung still not assessed, NT$16 million budgeted a year
From the early-intervention section of the National Audit Office report: 745 cases not yet taken in for assessment, 716 of them waiting over three months, set against a NT$16 million lottery-funded contract and the county's reply.
Watch and see the method → -
EP22 · Long-form
Number check
You published the books, I ran the numbers, they don't add up | NT$4,833,277 over four years, one firm, one bidder a year
We checked four years of Pingtung Youth Hub procurement notices, the 117 indicators in the 2026 administrative plan and the audited final accounts line by line. None of the three ledgers adds up.
Watch and see the method → -
EP22 · Shorts
Number check
Pingtung's own taxes flat for four years, spending keeps rising, and central money goes on fireworks?
We lined up Pingtung's local tax per person and spending per person from 2021 to 2025: a flat line against a steady climb.
Watch and see the method → -
EP29 · Shorts
Petition routing
The auditors asked Pingtung County to review early intervention; the county replied: deliberate, submit, discuss. The children wait.
Follow the paper trail from the auditors' request for review to the county's reply, and read the reply line by line to see which sentence has a deadline and which just sends the problem to a meeting.
Watch and see the method → -
EP16 · Long-form
Issue discovery
Pingtung's Artisan Town: the seismic assessment was done six years ago. Six and a half years and two magistrates later, what is the county waiting for?
We lined up every Artisan Town notice on the procurement portal: renovation first, assessment second, retrofit six and a half years after that. The retrofit and the management contract were both awarded at exactly budget, and the labor and youth director sat on both panels.
Watch and see the method → -
EP22 · Shorts
Number check
Pingtung Youth Hub: the same winner four years running, one bidder a year. Who is the proposal competing against?
We read four years of Pingtung Youth Hub tender and award notices and lined up bidders, winners and award against budget: the same firm, one bidder every year, all four awards exact to the dollar.
Watch and see the method → -
EP16 · Shorts
Petition routing
The central budget says "dangerous building": six and a half years from Artisan Town's seismic assessment to its retrofit. What is the county waiting for?
We matched the Ministry of Labor subsidy label, a freedom-of-information request and the county's one-line reply, then used two award notices to measure a six-and-a-half-year gap.
Watch and see the method → -
EP16 · Shorts
Number check
Artisan Town's retrofit: if safety matters this much, why wait until only 18 months are left on the lease?
We recalculated from the closure dates, tender notice and award notice: the county said ten months, it was 390 days; shops closed for 101 days before the county even found a contractor.
Watch and see the method → -
EP26R · Long-form
Number check
Pingtung's Research and Evaluation Department is the referee, and it also sits on Communications and Labor and Youth selection panels: is a referee playing in the game legal?
We used the county's own delegation table to confirm the Research and Evaluation Department is the referee, then went through the panel lists and attendance columns of 84 Communications selections and 54 selections listing the Labor and Youth director to count how often the referee played.
Watch and see the method → -
EP29 · Shorts
Number check
Pingtung County budgets NT$16 million a year to contract out early intervention, and on 25 March 745 cases were still sitting on the desk
Set the NT$16 million lottery-funded contract, the 745 cases waiting on 25 March 2026 and three years of childcare reports (29, 16, 12) side by side.
Watch and see the method → -
EP28 · Long-form
Issue discovery
Pingtung had Taiwan's highest August rainfall. The National Audit Office: 90 of 92 drainage channels have no completed management plan
We read out, cell by cell, the tables on Pingtung in the National Audit Office's 2025 Forward-looking Infrastructure audit report: regional drainage, stormwater sewers and the Heart of the Tribe centers, next to this August's rainfall.
Watch and see the method → -
EP26R · Shorts
Number check
Pingtung's Labor and Youth director picks contractors at the same table as the Research and Evaluation section chief who grades him. Is that legal?
Taking the 54 selection notices that list the Labor and Youth director, we checked each one for the same Research and Evaluation section chief and whether both attendance fields say "Yes".
Watch and see the method → -
EP26R · Shorts
Issue discovery
Pingtung's Research and Evaluation Department takes a panel seat, then grades Communications and Labor and Youth at year-end. Who keeps score?
We put the Research and Evaluation Department's grading duties, its seats on selection panels and the two records the county keeps private side by side, and found the one question no one can check.
Watch and see the method →